| ID | Category | Title | Creator | Status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 | balance | Use team spawn points (if any) by default in Clan Arena (g_ca_team_spawns 1). | bones_was_here | PASSED | 3:1(5 abstained, 17 didn't vote) |
-
| User | Decision | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Freddy | ABSTAIN | I think this is personal preference whether one prefers tactical gameplay or chaos. |
| Antibody | NONE | |
| Arch | NONE | |
| bones_was_here | ABSTAIN | CA is rather unpopular here... |
| carnag3 | YES | players spawning at their respective base spawn points is logical |
| Cloudwalk | NONE | |
| divVerent | YES | That's what team spawns are for; if this is a problem on some maps, the maps should be fixed. Also it matches other games with CA-like gameplay (e.g. Counterstrike) and generally leads to deeper gameplay. Do provide opt-out for server admin or on a per-map basis via mapinfo to easily handle maps not handling it well. |
| Dodger | NONE | |
| Dr. Jaska | NO | With several years of CA experience personally I see CA being far more fun when it's well shuffled chaos and have observed active long time CA players also thinking alike. I only see this change promoting trenchwars where neither team wants to engage the other one but only poke each other at long range. Pub CA players are unlikely to properly coordinate attacks and when both teams are together it doesn't make any sense to attempt to push against the other team alone in a game like Xonotic. |
| ferreum | NONE | |
| Halogene | NONE | |
| hotdog_the | NONE | |
| illwieckz | NONE | |
| LegendGuard | NONE | |
| Morosophos | NONE | |
| MrBougo | NONE | |
| nitroxis | NONE | |
| pcl0l | NONE | |
| rly_xa | ABSTAIN | Not a gametype I have played much at all |
| J.R. | NONE | |
| Silent | NONE | |
| SPLAT | NONE | |
| Spike29 | ABSTAIN | Initially voted yes, but on second thought going to abstain, as some people prefer tactical "trenchware" gameplay while others prefer more chaotic gameplay (I prefer the former). In any case, only CTF maps that are open enough (like Dance and Implosion currently) should have the ca gametype IMHO, maps that are too closed such as Catharsis or Vorix are not suitable to CA. |
| terencehill | YES | |
| turkey_shoot | ABSTAIN | |
| z411 | NONE |