Balance Council(#9)

Back

ID	Category	Title	Creator	Status	Result
9	membership	Allow Balance Council admins to temporarily remove voting rights from members deemed inactive and unparticipating, but requiring restoration of their rights once said member wishes to be active and participate again	Dr. Jaska	FAILED	1:6(3 abstained, 8 didn't vote)

2023-06-13T20:52:43Z - 2023-06-23T20:52:43Z

User	Decision	Comment
Freddy	NO	Balance changes should not be rushed. The purpose of this vote seems to be to push something into the next release.
Antibody	NO
Arch	ABSTAIN
bones_was_here	NO	This vote is unenforceable/invalid because the people repeatedly identified as "inactive" are team members, and the balance council does not have the authority to remove a team member's voting rights. See: https://xonotic.org/balance_council
Cloudwalk	ABSTAIN
divVerent	NONE
Dr. Jaska	YES	It is currently impossible to achieve a supermajority thanks to one third being completely dead, this slows down even the completely unanimous votes and makes 30 days the mandatory wait time regardless that all members which are expected to participate already have done so.
Halogene	NO	I feel personally addressed o.O
illwieckz	NONE
LegendGuard	NONE
Morosophos	NONE
MrBougo	NONE
nitroxis	NONE
Silent	NONE
SPLAT	NONE
Spike29	NO	We all have our lives and occupations and aren't meant to be active all the time. Some people may also not vote for lack of interest in the proposed changes (in which case it's probably best to vote "abstain") but may still want to make their voices heard in other votes. Besides, there's no hurry, waiting one month for a vote to end is not the end of the world.
terencehill	NO	we should first define precise rules for considering a Balance Council member inactive
z411	ABSTAIN