Team Votes(#232)

Back

ID	Category	Title	Creator	Status	Result
232	legacy	Never allow on default maps the placement of warpzones unless their presence is explicitly clarified (i.e. with a visual effect such as on stormkeep, or a type of picture frame outline)-- This also means updating glowplant so that the warpzone there has a visual effect.	Samual	PASSED	7:2(2 abstained, 12 didn't vote)

2014-02-21T04:31:15Z - 2014-03-03T04:31:38Z

User	Decision	Comment
Antibody	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
divVerent	YES	assuming 233 passes. Otherwise WILL_VETO.
Halogene	NO	I actually think warpzones that are barely or even not at all noticeable are a very interesting feature of Xonotic and I don't see why we should prevent default maps to show off this. Glowplant warpzone is brilliant the way it is imho.
MrBougo	ABSTAIN
terencehill	YES	but with exceptions for maps where it's obvious or unavoidable (not the common case)
Archer	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
bitbomb	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
CuBe0wL	YES	Ok, however there will be always need for special cases of non-visible seamless warpzones, so let's not remove the shaders supporting that (eg. limbo map)
detrate	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
GATTS	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
IDWMaster	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
JH0nny	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
kuniu	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
Mario	YES
matthiaskrgr	NO	wtf?! fix your code instead... aren't warpzones one of he things which make xonotic quite unique? I never had problems with the warpzones there. If people are too fucking dumb for warpzones they shall just play another map.
Mirio	ABSTAIN
packer	YES
s1lence	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
Samual	YES	I think this is incredibly important for usability purposes, i've seen enough complaints about glowplant and its confusing warpzone alone.. Fixing this would provide consistency to users, and it would I think strengthen the fidelity of the game.
sev	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
Soelen	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
Sydes	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
zykure	YES	I'll trust Samual on this one...