| ID | Category | Title | Creator | Status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 274 | legacy | Clean up and merge siege (http://forums.xonotic.org/showthread.php?tid=1174) | Mario | FAILED | 1:3(1 abstained, 22 didn't vote) |
-
| User | Decision | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Antibody | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| divVerent | YES | I do insist on the technicalities, especially that we use the sRGB correct lighting. Please tell me when you think it's ok, I will review then (but essentially, if you have no special -light settings, it's okay) |
| Halogene | NO | I think the map lacks a ... layout that is worth spending more time on. It looks nice, but gameplay-wise it's just an open arena with two tunnels. |
| MrBougo | ABSTAIN | I'm sadly unaware of siege |
| Nitroxis | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Archer | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| bitbomb | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| CuBe0wL | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Debugger | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| detrate | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| FruitieX | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| GATTS | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| IDWMaster | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| JH0nny | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| kuniu | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Mario | NO | Needs gameplay testing and community opinions - http://dl.smbclan.net/maps/siege.pk3 |
| merlijn | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Mirio | NO | This map is not that great with gameplay, there are likely more maps that are worth it |
| packer | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| s1lence | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Samual | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| sev | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Soelen | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Sydes | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| theShadow | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| unfa | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| zykure | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |