| ID | Category | Title | Creator | Status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 32 | legacy | Allow IP addresses to be tracked in Xonstat for purposes of displaying and storing geolocation information on players, essentially so that we can display country/region flags in game or on the Xonotic statistics pages | Samual | CANCELED | 1:4(1 abstained, 0 didn't vote) |
-
| User | Decision | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| divVerent | NO | This is a major privacy issue. I would rather prefer shipping a geolocation DB with Xonotic, and having the game server tell the stats server only the country. |
| Debugger | NO | Better solution (e.g. for more privacy): Let the player pick his country flag in the player setup |
| matthiaskrgr | ABSTAIN | |
| Mirio | NO | |
| Samual | YES | If someone joins a server, their IP is not private with respect to the server anyway. We can provide an opt-out cvar for this kind of tracking, similar to the uid2name tracking, however as long as we don't provide a public interface to see these IPs, I see no problem with collecting geolocation information |
| zykure | NO | that should just be an user option, iirc there were already discussions about this |