| ID | Category | Title | Creator | Status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 357 | legacy | Factor in latency to the Elo algorithm. Players with a latency disadvantage would get a boost and players without would get a decrease. Candidate formula: P1f = ((P1 ping/(P1 ping + P2 ping) - 0.5) * 2 + 1 | Antibody | PASSED | 5:1(3 abstained, 24 didn't vote) |
-
| User | Decision | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Freddy | ABSTAIN | a max/min factor of 1.5/0.5 seems too much, a linear progression seems wrong, how can we factor in packet loss? |
| Antibody | YES | |
| divVerent | YES | As long as this doesn't change the assumed winning probability, but just the points delta scaling, this is fine, as said scaling is ad-hoc anyway. |
| Nitroxis | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| AllieWay | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Archer | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| bitbomb | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| BuddyFriendGuy | YES | |
| CuBe0wL | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Debugger | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Diomedes | NO | |
| FruitieX | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| GATTS | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| IDWMaster | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| JH0nny | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Jubilant | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| kuniu | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| martin--t | YES | in favor of the idea, don't know about the exact formula but after seeing discussion on irc trust you to come up with something reasonable |
| matthiaskrgr | YES | |
| Melanosuchus | ABSTAIN | |
| merlijn | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Mirio | ABSTAIN | |
| Morphed | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| nyov | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| s1lence | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Samual | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| sev | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Soelen | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Sydes | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| theShadow | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| TimePath | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| unfa | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| zykure | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |