| ID | Category | Title | Creator | Status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 391 | legacy | Set default bot skill to the maximum used in the campaign (10 or 11) so bots on servers are decent by default because they're there to temporarily replace players and players are usually even better. Alternatively, please suggest a different value. See https://gitlab.com/xonotic/xonotic-data.pk3dir/merge_requests/668 for details. | martin--t | FAILED | 2:5(1 abstained, 34 didn't vote) |
-
| User | Decision | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Freddy | NO | considering that quite a few newbies get stuck on the later campain levels, bots on servers and in local matches should not be too strong. Skill 8 like suggested by terencehill seems fine |
| Antibody | NO | I don't think they should be 4, but they also shouldn't be at the "timing items" level of complexity. 8 seems like a good recommendation by terencehill. |
| divVerent | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Halogene | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| morosophos | YES | skilled bots can be disappointing for noobs, but facing a skilled player can be even more disappointing. So practicing against a top skilled bot is a good idea |
| MrBougo | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Nitroxis | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Spike29 | NO | On casual servers, killing bots should just be a way to warm up while waiting for other players, it shouldn't be too hard or too easy (skill 8 as suggested by terencehill looks like a good compromise). |
| terencehill | NO | skill 8 because bots have a somewhat decent aim, can be spectated (not very nervous movements), can bunnyhopping but don't "time" items (a skill that is considered very advanced for most players, even though what bots do is a rough timing) |
| AllieWay | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Archer | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| bitbomb | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| BuddyFriendGuy | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| CuBe0wL | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Debugger | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| detrate | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Diomedes | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| FruitieX | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| GATTS | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| IDWMaster | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| JH0nny | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Jubilant | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| kuniu | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| maikmerten | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Mario | NO | Practice against bots should always give even a newbie the upper hand, there's nothing more annoying than a bot out-skilling you when you're trying to learn or try out new weapons, they aren't replacements for humans |
| martin--t | YES | |
| matthiaskrgr | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Melanosuchus | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| merlijn | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Mirio | ABSTAIN | |
| Morphed | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| nyov | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| packer | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| s1lence | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Samual | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| sev | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Soelen | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| Sydes | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| theShadow | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| TimePath | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| unfa | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| zykure | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |