Team Votes(#405)

Back

ID	Category	Title	Creator	Status	Result
405	legacy	Remove Martin from the extended team. Contributions ceased over a year ago, has been known to be actively slandering the team in the meantime	Mario	TIED	4:4(2 abstained, 7 didn't vote)

2021-02-26T13:29:43Z - 2021-03-08T13:30:41Z

User	Decision	Comment
Freddy	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
Antibody	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
bones_was_here	NO	martin--t has requested a chance to defend. I support a second chance IF martin--t commits to improving his attitude, being supportive of the xon project in public, keeping discussions of grievances in the team channel
Cloudwalk	YES	I have seen strong evidence (and also have personal experience) of a pervasive pattern of toxicity in and around the Xonotic community that has scared off new players. There have been numerous, persistent attempts to disparage and slander Mario with baseless accusations of malfeasance. Whether or not these claims hold any weight, the evidence of Martin's wrongdoing holds stronger in my book.
divVerent	ABSTAIN	Pro: lack of recent contributions (but he says it'll flare back up now that exams are done), gathering dirt on other team members, unwelcoming behavior towards other players and developers (seen evidence). Contra: still seems below the threshold to me, and if this is enough to ban, maybe there's others too. If unwelcoming behavior repeats I'll be fully in favor though.
Halogene	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
morosophos	NO	ok, everyone has his right to defend
MrBougo	ABSTAIN	Unfortunately not familiar enough with the history to either feel comfortable voting yes or know if there is a way forward. However this seems serious enough to warrant a warning.
Nitroxis	NO	I suppose he deserves time to explain himself, although I don't wish to take sides in this drama
Spike29	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
terencehill	YES	his deep personal issues with Mario led him to completely cease IRC/gitlab activity altogether, issues caused mainly by his attitude and actions. I'll vote yes to readmit him if he stops his hostility towards Mario and starts collaborating again in any way.
BuddyFriendGuy	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
detrate	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)
Mario	YES	Not much to add here - his behaviour has been harmful to the community and development team long before his departure
martin--t	NO
Mirio	YES
packer	NONE	(auto-abstain due to inactivity)