| ID | Category | Title | Creator | Status | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 407 | legacy | Remove martin--t from the extended team. | Antibody | PASSED | 10:0(0 abstained, 4 didn't vote) |
-
| User | Decision | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Freddy | YES | He had his chance to defend, but only used that time to attack others. Whether it's anger management issues or malicious intent doesn't matter. No teammember should show this sort of behavior. |
| Antibody | YES | Repeated insults targeted at the developer community and one individual in particular. |
| bones_was_here | YES | Inside every cynic, is a disappointed optimist. I had hoped for a happier ending to this story, but it's clear there won't be one. |
| Cloudwalk | YES | Persistent pattern of toxicity in and around the Xonotic community |
| divVerent | YES | Public slandering of dev team, resentfulness (http://rm.cloudns.org/img/uploaded/b0736d74bbdb78ae3d2e895c5455638f.png) and actually having caused major damage to team coherence. This is WORSE than some supposed minor manipulative behavior (which to me looked more like some talking-before-thinking). Also, digging up dirt on other members than just the "main target" via PM. |
| Halogene | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| morosophos | YES | systematic public slandering of xonotic game and dev team and no proper amends of it |
| MrBougo | YES | I take issue both with how martin has dealt his cards over the past few months, and with how the team has received it. Charity is long gone. Unfortunately I don't see another way of getting us out of the present toxic stalemate than letting this vote pass. |
| Nitroxis | YES | He convinced me to vote no on the previous poll to get more time to defend, but there is no defense happening, just more of the harmful toxicity that appears to have been going on for at least a year. His repeated use of abusive language alone warrants a kick IMO, but since his behaviour and personal vendetta is actively harming this community, I really see no alternative. |
| Spike29 | YES | By slandering the Xonotic team and with his preposterous lonely crusade against one dev in particular, he is sowing the seed of discord in the team and hurting the whole community as a result. |
| terencehill | YES | He continued to attack mario instead of apologizing for his own faults, following his plan of trying to get rid of mario at any cost. In general his superior attitude and obsessive behaviour make him unable to behave well in a community and in a team in particular. |
| BuddyFriendGuy | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| detrate | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |
| packer | NONE | (auto-abstain due to inactivity) |