Team Votes(#419)

Back

ID	Category	Title	Creator	Status	Result
419	maps	Add Bloody Run to official maps (Bloodrun remake): https://gitlab.com/xonotic/xonotic-maps.pk3dir/-/merge_requests/151	Spike29	TIED	1:1(3 abstained, 6 didn't vote)

2022-01-01T10:14:55Z - 2022-01-16T10:14:55Z

User	Decision	Comment
Freddy	ABSTAIN	Consistent style. Seems to be clipped properly. Some parts outside seem like they can be reached, but are clipped. Spacing might need some adjustment in some areas (teleporter exit to MA). I haven't played it in a real match, so I have to rely on other opinions.
Antibody	NO	It's just too "busy" for me. Lighting is all over the place and there are features on every inch of every wall, trapping mortars and the like. It doesn't seem like a good fit IMHO.
bones_was_here	YES	when it has been polished more in response to Team's criticisms, so it should target the Xonotic version after 0.8.5. Players like it (especially it's appearance) and support making it official but have made similar criticisms to the Team.
Cloudwalk	NONE
divVerent	ABSTAIN	sorry, have not tested, trusting the rest of the team on that
Halogene	NONE
morosophos	NONE
MrBougo	NONE
Nitroxis	NONE
Spike29	ABSTAIN	The map appearance is good in general but there are a few issues (that could probably be fixed): some wall details should have weapon clips, many places are accessible in appearance but clipped, inconsistent sizing in some places (Crylink ledge, door to MH). It seems like bloodrun_a3 is still the preferred remake of Blood Run for duels, but maybe that's just out of habit. While I'm not opposed to having Quake maps remakes in Xonotic (there are already a few), I'd rather have something new and exclusive to Xonotic.
terencehill	NONE